* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.
The Bronx buzzed with anticipation on Friday night as Juan Soto made his much-anticipated return to Yankee Stadium for the 2025 Subway Series opener. With the Yankees and Mets both leading their respective divisions, the atmosphere was electric—made even more intense by Soto's controversial departure from the Yankees to their crosstown rivals, the Mets. How do fans react when a star player switches teams and returns as an opponent? The scene was set for fireworks.
As Soto stepped onto the field to stretch, a wave of boos erupted from the Bleacher Creatures and fans throughout Yankee Stadium. "F--- Juan Soto!" echoed through the air, a sentiment that had been brewing since the moment he chose to leave the Bronx after a stellar season that saw him help take the Yankees to their first World Series appearance in 15 years. Despite the hostility, Soto managed to maintain his composure, subtly acknowledging the crowd while donning a thick skin. A true showman at heart, he seemed to relish the moment, even as fans expressed their anger through chants and signs.
This particular Subway Series was not just another chapter in the storied rivalry between the Yankees and the Mets; it was a showcase of the emotional highs and lows of sports fandom. With the two teams locked in a fierce battle for playoff positioning, the stakes were even higher. The rich history of this rivalry dates back decades, yet this match-up felt distinctly charged, marking one of the most anticipated meetings since the 2000 World Series.
Throughout the game, the tension remained palpable. While Soto was met with incessant jeers, it was the Yankees' new additions, Paul Goldschmidt and Cody Bellinger, who stole the spotlight. Both players contributed significantly to the Yankees' 6-2 victory, showcasing their abilities and proving that the franchise had a solid Plan B after Soto's departure. Goldschmidt recorded two hits and drove in two runs, while Bellinger banged out three hits and scored twice. The two had quickly made their mark in the Yankees lineup, demonstrating their skill and experience when it was needed the most.
In the third inning, the Yankees unleashed their fury on Mets starter Tylor Megill. Sending ten men to the plate, the Bronx Bombers scored four runs, with Goldschmidt's infield single pushing across a run, coupled with Francisco Lindor's throwing error that allowed another to score. The crowd roared, and it was clear that the home team was in control. Despite Soto's tactical prowess and sharp eye—drawing three walks—his offensive contribution fell flat, reflecting the emotional weight of his return.
As the game progressed, the rivalry between the two fanbases was on full display. Yankees fans expressed their discontent with Soto while also showing camaraderie with Mets fans, evident when a Knicks game score was displayed on the video board. This mix of competitiveness and shared love for sports is what makes New York such a vibrant city, where rivalry can coexist with respect.
The night concluded with Soto stepping to the plate in a pivotal moment, and while the Yankees hadn't allowed him to shine, it was Soto's ability to rise to the occasion that everyone had come to witness. Facing Luke Weaver, he hit a harmless fly ball to center field, sealing a bittersweet night for the former Yankee and proving that, despite the boos, the Bronx would always hold memories of his spectacular season with them.
Ultimately, this game underscored the essence of baseball and the emotional rollercoaster it brings. In sports, players come and go, but the memories and rivalries they create live on in the hearts of fans forever. As the Yankees emerged victorious, one thing was certain: The Bronx does not forget, and neither do its fans.
* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.