* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.
The landscape of college football recruiting is always shifting, and this year, it's particularly striking for Wisconsin Badgers football fans. In a surprising turn of events, local standout offensive lineman Sam Simpson from River Falls, Wisconsin has chosen to commit to Indiana University, a Big Ten rival, instead of staying in-state with the Badgers. This commitment has sparked discussions about the future of Wisconsin's recruiting strategy and its implications for the Badgers program.
Sam Simpson, a Class of 2026 three-star recruit, stands at 6 feet 4 inches and weighs 275 pounds. He is ranked as the No. 2 interior offensive lineman in Wisconsin and No. 48 nationally within his position group. Historically, the Badgers have been able to secure the top talent from their home state, but Simpson's decision to join Indiana marks a growing trend where elite in-state prospects are looking elsewhere.
What makes Simpson’s choice particularly noteworthy is his commitment to play under Bob Bostad, who has deep roots in Wisconsin football. Bostad, a former Wisconsin assistant coach, has developed a strong rapport with recruits due to his experience and knowledge of Midwestern football. His recent success at Indiana, with a 2024 season that included an impressive 11-2 record and a trip to the College Football Playoffs, has made the Hoosiers a more appealing option for players across the Big Ten.
Simpson expressed gratitude in his commitment announcement, thanking his family, friends, and coaches for their support throughout his journey. His decision to join the Hoosiers highlights a notable shift in recruitment dynamics, especially given Wisconsin's recent struggles in keeping top-tier talent within state borders.
This trend of in-state players committing to rival programs reflects larger issues at play within Wisconsin's recruiting strategy. Although Luke Fickell, the Badgers' head coach, has focused on establishing a strong recruiting footprint within a 300-mile radius, the diminishment of local talent presents challenges. Wisconsin has historically performed well on the recruiting trail, finishing 2024 and 2025 recruiting cycles ranked No. 23 and No. 25 nationally, respectively. However, the inability to secure top prospects like Simpson raises questions about the effectiveness of their strategy moving forward.
Simpson's commitment to Indiana could signify a trend where other top recruits from Wisconsin may consider heading to rival programs, especially if the Badgers cannot bolster their appeal. Furthermore, Indiana's recent recruiting exploits, which include signing 21 high school prospects in its previous class, show their upward trajectory in acquiring talent.
As college football fans, we must keep a close eye on how this will unfold for both Wisconsin and Indiana. With Bostad's influence and Indiana's newfound momentum, the Hoosiers might become a formidable force in the Big Ten, while the Badgers will need to adapt quickly to retain their crown as the preeminent college football team in Wisconsin.
The future of Wisconsin Badgers football recruiting hinges on several factors: the ability to attract local talent, the effectiveness of coaching, and the competitiveness within the Big Ten. As the landscape continues to evolve, all eyes will be on how both programs navigate these challenges in the coming years.
* This website participates in the Amazon Affiliate Program and earns from qualifying purchases.